Tankless Water Heater vs Tank: Which is Better for Your Home?

By Frank Gaborik | June 12, 2024

Tankless Water Heater vs Tank: Which is Better for Your Home?

which water heater is better

Tankless water heater vs tank? Choosing a tankless model can significantly impact your home’s energy efficiency and convenience. Tankless water heaters offer endless hot water on demand, which can be particularly appealing for larger households or homes with high hot water demands. But not all situations are ideal for the same type of water heater…

tankless water heater vs tank

Traditional tank water heaters are generally more affordable upfront and easier to install but can run out of hot water during peak usage times. The decision largely depends on your specific needs, budget, and long-term energy savings goals.

Both options have their own sets of advantages and potential drawbacks. By comparing their features, costs, and performance, you can make an informed decision that best suits your household.

Understanding Water Heaters

Water heaters come in various types, each with its mechanism to heat water. The functionality and efficiency of these water heaters differ significantly, impacting choices for homes and businesses.

Types of Water Heaters

Storage Tank Water Heaters
These are the most traditional systems. They operate by storing heated water in a large tank. The tank’s capacity varies, affecting the amount of hot water available at any time. These heaters can run on electricity, natural gas, propane, or oil. The main drawback is heat loss, known as standby heat loss, where energy is wasted while water sits unused in the tank.

Tankless Water Heaters
Also known as on-demand water heaters, they do not store hot water. Instead, they heat water directly as it flows through the unit. These systems can use either gas or electricity. They save energy by only heating water when needed and eliminating standby heat loss. However, the flow rate can be limited, meaning that simultaneous uses might be constrained.

How Water Heaters Work

Storage Tank Water Heaters
Storage tank systems have a thermostat to regulate water temperature. Cold water enters the tank, is heated by an internal element or burner, and remains stored until needed. When hot water exits, cold water refills the tank from the bottom, ensuring a constant supply. Insulation around the tank helps reduce standby heat loss but can’t eliminate it completely.

Tankless Water Heaters
These units activate when a hot water tap is turned on. An electric element or gas burner heats the water as it flows through a heat exchanger. This process delivers a continuous supply of hot water without the need for a storage tank. No energy is lost when the water is not being used, making tankless models more energy-efficient. The crucial factor is the flow rate, which can impact the simultaneous availability of hot water across multiple outlets.

Comparing Tankless and Tank Water Heaters

When deciding between tankless and tank water heaters, key factors to consider include efficiency, cost, space, and performance. This comparison aims to highlight the differences based on these critical aspects.

Efficiency and Energy Use

Tankless water heaters often boast higher energy efficiency, as they heat water only on demand, reducing standby heat loss. Many models achieve up to 98% efficiency, leading to noticeable energy savings on utility bills.

Tank water heaters, on the other hand, keep a large volume of water heated at all times, which can result in energy losses. Despite some newer models being more efficient, they typically linger around 60-70% efficiency. Fuel source also impacts efficiency: gas models are usually more efficient than electric ones.

Cost Factors

Initial costs for tankless water heaters are generally higher, ranging from $1,000 to $3,000, including installation. Their longevity and lower operating costs, however, may offset the upfront investment over time.

Tank water heaters usually have a lower purchase price, approximately $300 to $1,200. Installation is typically simpler and less expensive. Despite this, higher long-term energy costs and shorter lifespan—around 10-15 years compared to 20 years for tankless units—can make them more expensive in the long run.

Space Considerations

Tankless water heaters are compact and can be mounted on walls, requiring minimal space, which is ideal for smaller homes or properties with limited space.

Tank water heaters need a substantial footprint due to their large size, making them better suited to basements, utility rooms, or areas with more space. Space constraints can be a deciding factor for homeowners when choosing between the two types.

Performance and Flow Rate

Tankless water heaters provide continuous hot water, as they heat water directly and on demand. This makes them suitable for households with high usage, particularly if multiple units are installed. However, they may struggle to supply enough hot water simultaneously for large families.

Tank water heaters store a set amount of hot water, making them effective for regular, uninterrupted use. When the stored supply is depleted, it takes time to heat a new batch, which can be a drawback during periods of high demand. Tank size (commonly between 40-80 gallons) directly impacts flow rate and availability.

Advantages of Tankless Water Heaters

Tankless water heaters offer solutions for instant hot water, energy savings, and space efficiency. Their benefits make them an attractive option for many households.

Instant and On-Demand Hot Water

Tankless water heaters provide hot water precisely when needed. They heat water directly without using a storage tank, ensuring a continuous flow of hot water. This feature eliminates the waiting time associated with traditional heaters.

Water is heated as it passes through the unit, so homeowners do not run out of hot water even during extended use. This efficiency ensures that hot water is always available, making daily routines smoother and more convenient.

Long-Term Savings and Energy Costs

Tankless water heaters are known for their efficiency. They only operate when hot water is needed, reducing wasted energy. This efficient operation translates into lower utility bills for homeowners.

Traditional units keep a reservoir of water hot, which uses more energy. Tankless models avoid this by heating water only on demand. While the initial installation costs can be higher, the reduction in energy bills over time often compensates for the upfront expense.

Space Saving and Installation

These heaters are typically compact, freeing up valuable space in a home. They can be installed on walls or in small spaces where traditional water tanks wouldn’t fit. This flexibility is a significant advantage for homes with limited space.

The installation process is straightforward, often requiring less invasive procedures than traditional tanks. Although professional installation is recommended, the long-term benefits of saved space and efficiency are considerable.

Comparison Table:

FeatureTankless Water HeaterTraditional Water Heater
Hot Water AvailabilityOn-demand and instantStorage-dependent
Energy EfficiencyHigh due to on-demandLower, continuous heating
Space RequirementCompact, wall-mountedLarge, floor space
Installation CostsHigher initiallyLower initially
Long-Term Operating CostsLowerHigher

These advantages underscore the appeal of tankless water heaters, offering a blend of convenience, efficiency, and space-saving benefits.

Considerations for Tank Water Heaters

tankless vs tank water heater

Tank water heaters offer reliability and established technology but come with some notable factors to consider such as heat loss, installation costs, and maintenance requirements.

Likelihood of Standby Heat Loss

Storage tank water heaters typically store hot water in a tank. This can lead to standby heat loss, where heat escapes through the tank walls. Insulating the tank can reduce but not eliminate this loss. Over time, this results in higher energy usage as the heater must reheat water to maintain the set temperature.

Ease of Installation and Upfront Cost

The initial cost of tank water heaters is generally lower than tankless models. Installation is usually straightforward, especially in homes already set up for this system. However, the installation cost can vary depending on factors like the size of the tank and any necessary modifications to the plumbing or electrical systems.

Maintenance and Durability

Maintenance for tank water heaters includes periodic inspections and flushing to remove sediment build-up. Without regular maintenance, sediment can diminish heating efficiency and lead to premature failure. The typical lifespan of a tank water heater ranges from 8 to 12 years, but this can vary based on usage and maintenance practices. Proper upkeep can extend its service life.

Important Factors in Decision Making

are tankless water heaters good

Choosing between a tankless water heater and a traditional tank water heater depends on various factors. Each option has specific benefits and considerations that can impact efficiency, cost, and convenience in the long term.

Assessing Hot Water Needs

The decision hinges significantly on understanding hot water usage in the household. Tankless heaters provide an on-demand supply, meaning they can deliver continuous hot water as needed. Traditional tanks store a limited amount and may run out if usage exceeds capacity. This makes tankless heaters ideal for homes with variable or higher hot water demands.

Household Size and Demand

Smaller households with lower hot water demands might benefit more from a traditional tank, as they are less complex and easier to install. Conversely, larger households or those with frequent simultaneous usage, like showers and laundry, might find tankless systems more efficient. Tankless systems can serve multiple fixtures without depleting hot water, which is crucial for high-demand scenarios.

Energy Sources and Availability

Assessing which energy sources are available is crucial. Tankless heaters can be powered by natural gas, propane, or electricity. Gas-powered models often provide higher flow rates and may be more efficient compared to electric models. Conversely, traditional tank heaters also come in gas and electric options, but they tend to have higher standby energy loss, affecting overall efficiency.

Long-Term Considerations

Long-term costs include initial installation, maintenance, and operational costs. Tankless heaters often have a higher upfront cost but can save money in the long run due to increased energy efficiency and lower heating costs. Traditional tanks are generally less expensive initially but might have higher operational costs due to energy losses and potentially shorter lifespans.

In summary, evaluate your specific needs, including household size, energy source availability, and budget, to decide the best option for your home.

Installation and Maintenance

what is a tankless water heater

Proper installation and regular maintenance are essential for both tankless water heaters and traditional tank water heaters. Each system has unique requirements that can influence the overall cost and effort involved.

Professional Installation by a Plumber

Installing a tankless water heater typically requires the expertise of a plumber due to the complexity of the job. These units often need upgraded gas lines, additional venting, and electrical work to function correctly. An experienced plumber ensures that everything complies with local codes and operates safely.

For traditional tank water heaters, the installation process can be less complicated but still requires professional attention. Ensuring correct connections to water lines and proper venting is crucial to prevent potential hazards. While the initial cost might be lower compared to tankless units, the work involved should not be underestimated.

Ongoing Care and Upkeep

Tankless water heaters demand regular maintenance to maintain efficiency. This includes descaling to prevent mineral buildup, which is essential in areas with hard water. A plumber can ensure these units remain in optimal condition through annual checks and necessary repairs.

Traditional tank water heaters also require consistent upkeep, focusing primarily on flushing the tank to remove sediment build-up. Additionally, inspecting the anode rod helps in preventing rust and extending the unit’s lifespan. Regular maintenance by a professional can reduce the risk of leaks and ensure consistent hot water availability.

Popular Water Heater Brands and Manufacturers

brands like Rheem and tagaki

Choosing the right water heater involves considering well-known brands and their reliability, as well as cost factors. This section explores the reliability of popular brands and how cost considerations impact your decision.

Comparing Brand Reliability

When it comes to reliability, Rheem, Takagi, Bosch, and Rinnai are frequently mentioned. Rheem offers a broad range of products known for their durability and long-lasting performance. Bosch is often praised for its energy-efficient models that feature advanced technology. Rinnai is known for its innovative tankless water heaters, which provide on-demand hot water efficiently.

Each brand has built a reputation based on quality and customer satisfaction. Users have reported fewer issues with Rheem, Takagi, and Bosch, while Rinnai stands out for its less frequent need for maintenance.

Cost vs. Brand Considerations

Each brand comes with different price tags and value propositions. Rheem products are often cost-effective, making them a good choice for budget-conscious buyers. On the other hand, Bosch and Rinnai tend to have higher initial purchase prices but offer savings through lower energy consumption over time.

For those looking at long-term investments, Rinnai offers compelling benefits despite a higher upfront cost. Bosch also provides good energy efficiency, which can lower utility bills. Ultimately, the decision requires balancing initial costs with long-term savings.

Frequently Asked Questions

A tankless water heater and a traditional tank water heater side by side, with question marks floating above them

Tankless water heaters differ significantly from traditional tank models in cost, performance, and efficiency. Here are some common questions to help you decide which one suits your needs.

What are the cost differences between tankless and tank water heaters?

Upfront, tankless water heaters are generally more expensive than traditional tank models. Tankless units can cost more to purchase and install due to specialized equipment and possibly higher labor costs. In contrast, tank water heaters are usually cheaper to buy and install initially.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of tankless water heaters compared to traditional tank models?

Tankless water heaters provide endless hot water and are more energy-efficient since they heat water on demand. They are also more compact, saving space. Traditional tank models, while less energy-efficient, can be less expensive initially and easier to install. They also have the advantage of providing a reserve of hot water during power outages.

How do electric tankless water heaters compare to their tank counterparts in terms of performance and energy efficiency?

Electric tankless water heaters are more energy-efficient since they only heat water when needed, reducing standby energy losses. Performance-wise, they offer a constant supply of hot water on demand. Traditional electric tank heaters maintain a reservoir of hot water, leading to higher standby heat losses, but they can provide hot water even during short electricity outages.

Can a tankless water heater lead to long-term savings on utility bills?

Yes, a tankless water heater can lead to long-term savings on utility bills due to its higher energy efficiency. Since these units heat water only as needed, they avoid the constant energy consumption associated with keeping a tank of water heated, resulting in lower ongoing operational costs.

Are tankless water heaters a practical solution for most homes?

Tankless water heaters can be a practical solution for many homes, especially where space is limited or where the hot water demand is variable. They are particularly well-suited for smaller households or homes with higher hot water demands at different times. However, homes with very high simultaneous hot water usage may need more than one unit to meet demand.

What factors should be considered when deciding between a tankless water heater and a traditional tank model?

Consider the initial cost, installation complexity, and existing plumbing systems. Evaluate space available for the unit, energy efficiency, and long-term utility costs. Additionally, think about your household’s hot water usage patterns and the potential need for multiple tankless units to meet high demand.

Get Help NOW

Once you submit our form, we may reach out to you via phone, email, or text to communicate service details, which you can opt out of at any time. This form consent is not a condition of purchase. Message/data rates apply. Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.